How to Choose the Best Freight Agent Program

FREE RESOURCE

Discover the 10 steps to choosing your freight agent program

No fluff, no filler—just practical insights, real stories, and expert advice for freight brokers and agents.

FREIGHT BROKER INSIGHTS THAT ACTUALLY MATTER.

welcome to the somerset blog

Freight Broker Insurance: What Agents Need to Know After Montgomery

Somerset Logistics

by

November 16, 2026 4:45 am

Freight broker insurance moved from fine print to front page in 2026. Here’s what independent freight agents should know about coverage types, rising claims costs after the Montgomery ruling and the questions to ask your brokerage.

Post Date:

Freight Broker Insurance_ What Agents Need to Know After Montgomery

Freight broker insurance used to be a back-office topic that most agents never had to think about. That changed in 2026. The Supreme Court’s Montgomery decision in May opened brokers to negligent-selection claims, and by the end of October some of the largest brokerages in the country were reporting higher claims costs. If you sell freight under someone else’s authority, the brokerage’s insurance now shapes which carriers you can use, what your shippers ask you and how steady your brokerage partner stays.

This guide explains what freight broker insurance actually covers, why it’s getting more expensive and how it reaches an independent agent. It’s one of the risk topics in The Independent Freight Agent’s Handbook, and it picks up where our explainer on what the Montgomery ruling means for freight agents left off.

This article is general information, not legal or insurance advice. Your agent agreement and your brokerage’s actual policies decide how any of this applies to you.

Key Takeaways

  • The only financial protection federal rules require of a freight broker is $75,000 in security for unpaid freight charges, and it doesn’t cover accidents.
  • Contingent auto liability is the coverage that matters most after Montgomery, because it is designed for claims that a broker selected an unsafe carrier.
  • Claims costs climbed at large brokerages in the third quarter of 2026, and insurance industry voices expect broker premiums to keep rising.
  • Insurance costs can reach agents through stricter carrier approvals, new fees, split changes or shared deductibles, so the agent agreement deserves a close read.
  • A brokerage’s size doesn’t settle the question; its coverage, its documented carrier-selection process and its balance sheet do.

What Is Freight Broker Insurance?

Freight broker insurance is the set of bonds and policies a licensed brokerage carries to cover the financial risks of arranging freight. It isn’t one policy. Some pieces are required by federal rules, and others are business decisions the brokerage makes on its own or because shippers demand them.

The required piece is narrow. Under 49 CFR 387.307, a property broker must maintain $75,000 in financial security, filed as a surety bond (Form BMC-84) or a trust fund (Form BMC-85). FMCSA’s updated broker and freight forwarder financial responsibility rule, effective January 16, 2026, describes that security as a way to make sure funds are available for unpaid freight charges. It protects carriers and shippers who don’t get paid. It does nothing for an accident on the highway.

Everything else is coverage the brokerage chooses to buy.

The Coverage Types That Matter to Agents

Policy names and terms vary by insurer, so treat these as general categories rather than definitions of any specific policy.

CoverageWhat it generally addressesFederally required for brokers?
Surety bond or trust fund (BMC-84 / BMC-85)Unpaid freight charges owed to carriers and shippersYes, $75,000
Contingent auto liabilityClaims that the broker is responsible for a carrier’s accidentNo
Contingent cargoCargo losses when the carrier’s own cargo coverage doesn’t respondNo
General liabilityInjuries or property damage tied to the business, outside of drivingNo
Errors and omissionsFinancial losses caused by professional mistakes in arranging freightNo

Contingent Auto Liability

Contingent auto liability is the policy built for the situation Montgomery made more common. When a truck is involved in a serious crash and the injured party sues the broker that arranged the load, this coverage is designed to respond on the broker’s behalf. Limits, exclusions and conditions differ widely, and some policies tie coverage to how the broker vets and selects carriers.

Contingent Cargo

Contingent cargo coverage steps in when freight is lost or damaged and the carrier’s cargo insurance doesn’t pay, for example because of an exclusion or a lapsed policy. Agents feel this one directly, since a denied cargo claim usually turns into an unhappy shipper on your phone.

General Liability and Errors and Omissions

General liability covers ordinary business risks, such as someone getting hurt at an office. Errors and omissions coverage, sometimes called professional liability, addresses financial losses from mistakes like a booking or paperwork error. Shippers sometimes require both before they’ll tender freight.

Why the Montgomery Ruling Changed the Insurance Conversation

On May 14, 2026, the Supreme Court ruled 9-0 in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II that state-law negligent hiring and selection claims against brokers fall within the safety exception of the federal FAAAA, so federal law does not preempt them. Burr & Forman’s analysis notes that brokers lost preemption as an early defense, though plaintiffs still have to prove the broker failed to use reasonable care and that its carrier choice caused the harm.

That shift lands squarely on contingent auto liability. Before the ruling, many cases could be dismissed early in some federal circuits. Now more of them may go further, and that changes what insurers expect to pay. Days after the decision, FreightWaves reported that Transportation Intermediaries Association president Chris Burroughs was hearing of renewal increases as large as five times prior premiums, and that brokerage insurance had typically run 1% to 3% of revenue. Those were early, anecdotal reports, and TD Cowen’s analysts said it was too soon to quantify the impact.

What the Third Quarter of 2026 Showed

By late October, the effect started showing up in earnings. Landstar’s third-quarter 2026 results showed insurance and claims costs of $55.3 million, up from $33.0 million a year earlier. The company attributed much of the jump to adverse adjustments to its claim reserves and to settling a 2024 brokered truck accident claim.

FreightWaves reported that Landstar’s stock fell 17.8% and C.H. Robinson’s fell 11.1% on October 28, with claims expenses part of the story at both companies. Landstar’s CFO said two second-quarter claims came from federal jurisdictions where Montgomery removed the protection brokers had relied on. C.H. Robinson’s leadership, for its part, called its insurance expense small relative to revenue and said it expects 2027 insurance inflation to be manageable.

The takeaway isn’t that any one brokerage is in trouble. It’s that claims costs are now a live line item across the industry, from the largest brokers to the mid-size firms that renew their policies with much less negotiating power.

How Broker Insurance Reaches an Independent Agent

As a 1099 agent, you don’t buy your brokerage’s policies, but you work inside them every day. Here is where they show up.

Carrier Approvals

Insurers increasingly look at how a brokerage selects carriers. When underwriting tightens, approval rules usually tighten too: more carriers flagged, longer reviews and fewer exceptions. If you’ve noticed carrier vetting taking longer, insurance is often part of the reason.

Shipper Questions

Shippers may ask a broker for a certificate of insurance, its contingent auto limits or a description of its carrier-selection process. You’ll field those questions first, so it helps to know the answers before a customer asks.

Costs That Move Downstream

Higher premiums have to be paid by someone. Some programs absorb them. Others add a fee, adjust splits or ask agents to share a deductible when a claim involves their load. None of that is automatically unfair, but it should be written down. Our field guide to hidden fees in freight agent programs and the explainer on what a bad-debt chargeback is cover how to read those terms.

Your Brokerage’s Staying Power

A large claim that lands below a brokerage’s deductible, or above its limits, is paid from its own balance sheet. That’s why insurance and financial strength belong in the same conversation. Our guide on how freight agents evaluate brokerage stability walks through the financial side.

Is a Bigger Brokerage Automatically Safer?

Not automatically. Some large agent networks have pitched their scale as a safe haven for brokers and agents worried about Montgomery, as CCJ reported after third-quarter earnings calls. Scale can buy higher limits and more negotiating leverage with insurers. It also comes with more loads, more exposure and, as the third quarter showed, bigger claims charges.

Size describes a company’s shape, not how well it manages risk. The questions that decide whether a brokerage is a safe home for your book are more specific: how much coverage it carries, how it documents carrier selection, how it handles a claim and whether its balance sheet can absorb a bad year. Justice Kavanaugh’s concurrence in Montgomery points the same way, suggesting that brokers who act reasonably and use reputable carriers should be able to defend these suits. For more on the trade-offs of scale, see what size brokerage is best for freight agents.

Questions to Ask About Your Brokerage’s Insurance

You don’t need to become an insurance expert. You do need clear answers to a few questions, ideally in writing.

  1. Which policies do you carry, and what are the limits on contingent auto liability and contingent cargo? Can I see a current certificate of insurance?
  2. Did your coverage, limits or deductibles change at your most recent renewal?
  3. Does your policy require specific carrier-selection steps, and how does your process document them?
  4. Are any insurance costs passed to agents through fees, split changes or deductibles?
  5. If a claim involves one of my loads, who pays the deductible and what’s expected of me?
  6. How quickly can you send a certificate of insurance to a new shipper?
  7. Does my agent agreement require me to carry any coverage of my own?

If you’re comparing programs, add these to your checklist of what to ask before joining a freight agent program.

Do Freight Agents Need Their Own Insurance?

Usually the brokerage’s bond and policies cover the loads you arrange under its authority, because the brokerage is the party that holds the operating authority and contracts with shippers and carriers. That doesn’t settle every question. Some agent agreements require agents to carry their own general liability or errors and omissions coverage, and agents with their own office, employees or sub-agents may need business coverage of their own.

Read your agreement, ask the brokerage directly and talk with a licensed insurance professional about your specific setup.

Where Somerset Stands

Somerset runs a freight agent program, so we’re not a neutral party on this topic. We’re a family-owned, veteran-founded brokerage that has been in business for 26 years and carries no debt. Our agents are 1099 independent contractors, and our program includes bad-debt protection with zero fees.

We’d rather you verify than take our word for it. Ask us the same seven questions above, request our certificate of insurance and ask how our carrier-selection process is documented. A good brokerage partner should be able to answer all of it plainly.

Freight Broker Insurance Is Worth a Direct Conversation

Freight broker insurance has moved from fine print to front page. Montgomery raised the stakes on carrier selection, claims costs are rising and the effects reach agents through carrier approvals, customer questions, costs and brokerage stability. The agents who come through this period in good shape will be the ones who asked their brokerage the hard questions early and got the answers in writing.

If you’d like to compare your current setup with ours, explore the Somerset freight agent program or reach out for a confidential conversation about your book.

Frequently Asked Questions

What insurance is a freight broker required to carry?

Federal rules require a property broker to maintain $75,000 in financial security, filed as a BMC-84 surety bond or a BMC-85 trust fund. That security exists to cover unpaid freight charges owed to carriers and shippers. Federal rules don’t require brokers to carry contingent auto liability, contingent cargo or general liability coverage, but most established brokerages buy them, and many shippers require them before tendering freight.

What is contingent auto liability insurance for freight brokers?

Contingent auto liability is coverage designed to respond when a freight broker is sued over an accident involving a carrier it hired. After the Supreme Court’s 2026 Montgomery decision allowed negligent-selection claims against brokers to proceed under state law, this coverage became more important. Limits and conditions vary, and some policies tie coverage to how the broker vets and selects carriers.

Does the Montgomery ruling make freight agents personally liable?

The Montgomery decision addresses claims against brokers, the companies that hold operating authority and select carriers. An independent agent’s own exposure depends on the agent agreement, how the load was handled and state law. Agents should ask their brokerage how claims involving their loads are handled and consult an attorney with specific concerns, since this is a legal question that general articles can’t answer.

Do independent freight agents need their own insurance?

Independent freight agents usually work under the brokerage’s bond and insurance for loads arranged under its authority. Some agent agreements still require agents to carry their own general liability or errors and omissions coverage. Agents who run an office, employ staff or work with sub-agents may need additional business coverage. The agent agreement and a licensed insurance professional are the best sources for a specific answer.

Are freight broker insurance costs going up in 2026?

Reports point to higher costs. After the Montgomery ruling in May 2026, the Transportation Intermediaries Association’s president said he was hearing of renewal increases as high as five times prior premiums, though analysts said the full impact was too soon to measure. By the third quarter of 2026, large brokerages including Landstar and C.H. Robinson reported higher claims expenses.

How can I find out what my brokerage’s insurance covers?

Ask for a current certificate of insurance, which lists policy types, insurers and limits. Then ask whether coverage, limits or deductibles changed at the last renewal, whether any insurance costs are passed to agents and who pays the deductible if a claim involves your load. A brokerage that answers these questions clearly and in writing is easier to trust with your book.

Many experienced freight agents reading this blog are evaluating their current brokerage environment.

FOR FREIGHT AGENTS CONSIDERING A NEW BROKERAGE

If you're asking questions like:

  • Is my brokerage financially stable?
  • Am I competing wtih too many other agents?
  • Do I truly own my customer relationships?

It may be worth exploring the somerset difference

How to Choose the Best Freight agent program

FREE RESOURCE