How to Choose the Best Freight Agent Program

FREE RESOURCE

Discover the 10 steps to choosing your freight agent program

No fluff, no filler—just practical insights, real stories, and expert advice for freight brokers and agents.

FREIGHT BROKER INSIGHTS THAT ACTUALLY MATTER.

welcome to the somerset blog

Freight Broker Insurance Cost: Why the Montgomery Squeeze Hits Small Brokers Hardest

Somerset Logistics

by

November 13, 2026 2:20 pm

Freight broker insurance cost is rising after the Montgomery ruling, and the squeeze is sharpest for small and one-person brokerages. Here is what the reporting shows so far, why smaller brokers have fewer options, and what to ask before choosing a path.

Post Date:

Freight Broker Insurance Cost_ Why the Montgomery Squeeze Hits Small Brokers Hardest

Key Takeaways

  • Freight broker insurance cost has risen since the Supreme Court’s May 14, 2026 Montgomery decision, which let state-law negligent-selection claims against brokers move forward.
  • Reported increases vary widely: one top-10 broker’s liability premium tripled, TD Cowen estimates mid-teens to mid-20s percent increases for large brokers, and SONAR reports primary coverage up roughly 40 to 60 percent. None of these is an industry average.
  • About ten underwriters remain in broker auto liability after two recent exits, which limits how much a broker can shop for a better quote.
  • Small brokers have the least room to absorb the cost, and TD Cowen’s panelist expects consolidation over time. That is one expectation, not a certainty.
  • A small broker’s broad options are to stay independent, bring their book under a larger brokerage as an agent while keeping their customers, or merge or sell, and each trades some control for relief.

Figures last checked November 6, 2026.

What Freight Broker Insurance Cost Means

Freight broker insurance cost is what a licensed freight brokerage pays for the bonds and policies that protect its business, including the federally required $75,000 surety bond or trust fund and optional coverage such as contingent auto liability, contingent cargo, general liability and errors and omissions. The amount varies with coverage limits, layers, claims history and the size of the operation.

What Changed for Freight Broker Insurance Cost

On May 14, 2026, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II that state-law claims alleging a broker negligently chose a carrier can move forward. Burr & Forman’s analysis notes the ruling does not make brokers automatically liable, since plaintiffs still have to prove the broker failed to use reasonable care and that the choice caused the harm. What it removed was an early defense many brokers had relied on.

Insurers reacted fast. FreightWaves reported that an insurance executive consulted by TD Cowen saw rates spike after the ruling, ease, and then jump again after a late-July jury verdict in Lipe v. Lupus Superior. SONAR reports that verdict exceeded $900 million, with C.H. Robinson facing more than $600 million of it as broker of record.

The executive read that back-and-forth as a sign insurers have not yet settled on how to price this risk. That uncertainty is a big part of why the cost question is hard to answer today.

What the Numbers Show So Far

The published figures all point the same direction, but they come from a handful of sources and do not add up to an industry average.

Reported figureWhat it describesSource
Liability premium tripled at renewalOne unnamed top-10 brokerFreightWaves, citing TD Cowen
Mid-teens to mid-20s percent increasesTD Cowen’s estimate for large brokersFreightWaves, citing TD Cowen
$3 million to $10 millionOne large broker’s excess layer, sitting above $15 million of primary coverageFreightWaves, citing TD Cowen
About 10 underwriters, two recent exits, possibly down to eightThe broker auto liability marketFreightWaves, citing TD Cowen
Roughly 40 to 60 percentPrimary coverage at renewal, per SONARSONAR
From about $10,000 up to between $30,000 and $40,000 a yearBrokers with $30 to $40 million in revenue; SONAR does not say which coverageSONAR

Treat these carefully. FreightWaves itself described the TD Cowen outlook as a single report and the words of one person quoted in it. In May, early estimates reported by FreightWaves ranged from a threefold increase to as much as fivefold, and TD Cowen said at the time it was too soon to quantify the impact.

Why Small Brokers Feel the Cost Most

Small brokers are exposed on several fronts at once, according to the TD Cowen reporting and the large brokers’ own comments.

  • Fewer places to shop. With about ten underwriters in the market and two already gone, a broker who gets a bad quote has little leverage to find a better one.
  • Margin pressure. TD Cowen’s report expects insurance headwinds to squeeze margins, and a cost jump of three to four times is hardest on a small operation. That multiple comes from SONAR’s small-broker example above.
  • More scrutiny from shippers. The report says small brokers will face closer questions from their shipper base, which could hurt their top line.
  • Fewer ways to structure around it. FreightWaves reported that C.H. Robinson holds $135 million in auto liability limits with a $10 million per-claim deductible, a setup TD Cowen compared to how large carriers insure. RXO’s chief strategy officer credited its safety record and compliance processes for outperforming on rate increases. Neither option is easy for a one-person shop.
  • Less leverage for newer and smaller accounts. Insurance wholesaler Amwins wrote in July that underwriters are putting more weight on experience and established relationships, which may make it harder for newer or smaller brokers to get coverage on favorable terms. It added that minimum premiums are becoming more common, regardless of account size.

Large brokers also expect to pass the cost along. C.H. Robinson’s CEO said it will eventually become part of every load quoted and be passed on to shippers and consumers. A small broker competing on price has less room to do the same.

TD Cowen’s panelist expects consolidation over time. FreightWaves reports roughly 22,000 brokers operate in the industry, with the top 100 controlling 84 percent of it. That is one person’s expectation, not a forecast anyone can guarantee.

The Paperwork Behind the Price

Beyond price, underwriters are asking brokers to show how they choose carriers.

The underwriter Amwins includes a list of motor carriers with DOT numbers and a sample broker-carrier agreement among the requirements for its freight broker application. Its July 27 article says higher insurance costs, stricter underwriting requirements and greater expectations around carrier oversight and documentation are already taking effect after the ruling.

That pressure runs down to carriers too. In May, TD Cowen’s panel estimated that mid to high single digits of trucking capacity could be removed from the market as brokers drop carriers with unresolved safety issues, according to FreightWaves.

For a large brokerage, assembling this evidence is a staffing question. For a one-person shop, the work falls on one person, on top of everything else a broker does in a day.

Two Readings of Why Premiums Are Moving

There are two ways people in the industry read what is happening, and both can be partly true.

The insurer view. In the TD Cowen reporting, the insurance executive said the swings in pricing show insurers are not yet comfortable with how much liability they are taking on, because the risk is still being assessed. The report also says appetite to reinsure the remaining underwriters has diminished, and that underwriters are still early in pricing and could see more inflation as they study loss rates.

The overcorrection view. Some brokers believe underwriters are pricing well beyond the risk and pushing premiums up until the legal and regulatory picture settles. We have not seen published evidence for or against that, and neither reading can be confirmed from outside the underwriting room.

Both readings agree on one thing: the cost is real today, and it lands hardest on the brokers least able to absorb it.

Options for a Small Broker

A small broker facing this squeeze has three broad paths, and each trades some control for relief.

OptionWhat it involvesMain trade-off
Stay independentStart renewal preparation early, document how carriers are selected, and work with an insurance professional who knows brokersKeeps full control, but takes on the full cost and the paperwork alone
Bring your book under a larger brokerage as an agentKeep serving your customers as an independent agent, while the brokerage’s authority, bond and policies typically cover the loadsLess insurance burden, but you follow the brokerage’s carrier approvals, agreement and pay terms
Merge with or sell to another brokerageCombine operations or exitCan preserve the value of your book, but means giving up independence and takes time

Timing matters on the first path. The insurance executive in the TD Cowen reporting said when you renew affects what you pay, since rates have swung since May.

Somerset runs a freight agent program, so we are not a neutral party here. If working under a larger brokerage appeals to you, ask any brokerage the questions further down, and have an attorney review any agreement before you move your book. The next section walks through what usually stays with you and what changes.

Bringing Your Book Under a Larger Brokerage

For a broker who spent years building a customer list, this path is less about giving something up and more about deciding which parts of the business you want to keep running yourself. The idea is to keep what you built and hand off the overhead. How well that works depends on the agreement, so it helps to know what usually stays with you and what changes.

What You Keep

You keep the shipper relationships you built, your knowledge of their freight and the way you serve them. In a well-written agent agreement, the customers you bring are listed as yours and stay yours if you later leave. Get that in writing before you move anything. Our guide to protecting your book of business before changing brokerages covers what to look for.

What the Brokerage Takes On

Loads move under the brokerage’s operating authority, so its bond or trust fund and its insurance policies typically cover them instead of yours. The brokerage also usually handles carrier vetting, invoicing, collections and carrier pay. Which policies and limits apply to your loads is something to confirm in writing, not assume.

What Changes

You work within the brokerage’s carrier approvals, agreement terms and commission split instead of setting all of those yourself. Your shipper contracts may need to move into the brokerage’s name, since it becomes the party of record on the loads. Whether you keep your own MC number and company, or let that authority go inactive, depends on the arrangement. If you keep your own broker authority active, the federal $75,000 bond or trust fund requirement still applies to it.

A side-by-side comparison is a reasonable first step: your current premium, bond and back-office costs on one side, and a commission split with no back office to run on the other. Whichever way the numbers point, you’ll be choosing with the full picture in front of you.

Questions to Ask Before You Move Your Book

Before moving a book of business, get written answers to these questions from any brokerage you are considering.

  1. Which policies do you carry, and what are your limits on contingent auto and contingent cargo? Can I see a current certificate of insurance?
  2. Did your coverage, limits or deductibles change at your most recent renewal, and when is the next one?
  3. What carrier-selection steps does your insurer expect, and how do you document them?
  4. Are any insurance costs passed to agents through fees, split changes or deductibles?
  5. If a claim involves one of my loads, who pays the deductible and what is expected of me?
  6. What happens to my customer contracts and carrier relationships if I join, and if I later leave?
  7. Does your agreement require me to carry any coverage of my own?
  8. Do I keep my own MC number and company, or does my authority go inactive while I work with you?
  9. Are there any transition costs or incentives, and are they written into the agreement?

Our explainer on freight broker insurance for agents covers what each coverage type does, and our guide on what to ask before joining a freight agent program goes further on agreement terms.

A Conversation Is Always an Option

If you run a small brokerage and are weighing your options, we are glad to talk through what it would look like to keep your customers and relationships while working under a larger brokerage’s authority, with no pressure. You can start on our freight agent program page.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much has freight broker insurance cost gone up in 2026?

Reported figures vary by coverage layer and broker size. FreightWaves, citing TD Cowen, reported that one top-10 broker’s liability premium tripled and that large brokers are seeing mid-teens to mid-20s percent increases. SONAR reports primary coverage up roughly 40 to 60 percent at renewal. None of these figures is an industry average, so a specific quote can differ widely.

Why did freight broker insurance cost rise after the Montgomery ruling?

The May 14, 2026 decision removed an early legal defense brokers had relied on against negligent-selection claims. Insurers are repricing that risk, a July verdict of more than $900 million in Lipe v. Lupus Superior added to the concern, and about ten underwriters remain in broker auto liability after two recent exits.

Can small freight brokers afford the new insurance costs?

It depends on coverage, revenue and claims history. A panelist quoted by TD Cowen expects smaller brokers to face unsustainable insurance headwinds over time. That is one expectation, not a certainty, but it explains why many small brokers are weighing their options.

What should a small broker do before renewal?

Start early, document how carriers are selected, and work with an insurance professional who knows freight brokers. One industry vendor, Ark TMS, suggests beginning about 120 days before renewal.

Can a small freight broker become an agent and keep their customers?

Often, yes, but it depends on the agreement. A broker who joins a larger brokerage as an independent agent usually keeps working with the same shippers, while loads move under the larger brokerage’s authority, bond and insurance. Whether the broker keeps their own MC number and company, and whether those customers stay theirs if they later leave, depends on the agent agreement, so get both answers in writing before moving any freight.

Many experienced freight agents reading this blog are evaluating their current brokerage environment.

FOR FREIGHT AGENTS CONSIDERING A NEW BROKERAGE

If you're asking questions like:

  • Is my brokerage financially stable?
  • Am I competing wtih too many other agents?
  • Do I truly own my customer relationships?

It may be worth exploring the somerset difference

How to Choose the Best Freight agent program

FREE RESOURCE